U.S. speedskaters are third in team pursuit, but bronze feels like a letdown.

The United States finished third in speedskating’s team pursuit on Tuesday, collecting the second American speedskating medal of these Olympics. The United States men are the world record holders in the team pursuit and were favored to win the event, making the third-place finish equal parts success and disappointment.

The American team of Joey Mantia, Casey Dawson and Emery Lehman defeated the Netherlands in the so-called B final — effectively the bronze medal race — by almost three seconds. Norway won the gold, for the second Olympics in a row, defeating Russia in the final.

An unexpected decision potentially cost the United States a chance to race Norway in the final. Mantia, the most accomplished American skater, did not skate in the semifinals against a team from Russia, with Ethan Cepuran chosen instead by the team’s coach to race with Dawson and Lehman.

Dawson, Lehman and Cepuran skated well, leading through the middle of the race — their time of 3 minutes 37.05 seconds was faster than the Olympic record (and faster than they skated with Mantia in the B final). But the Russians skated an even better race, and won by almost half a second.

In the men’s team pursuit, the three team members skate in single file only inches apart for eight laps, with the time of the last skater to cross the finish line counted. Usually every lap or two the front skater, who does the grueling work of setting the pace while the others glide in his slipstream, peels to the back and lets a new teammate lead, and suffer.

As a group of individuals, the United States skaters are less accomplished than most of their opponents. None of them had won an Olympic medal before, and besides Mantia, none have come particularly close. Their opponents in the bronze medal race, the Dutch, were led by the nine-time Olympic medalist Sven Kramer and the four-time medalist Patrick Roest.

But the United States has prioritized the team pursuit over the past four years, eventually overtaking the rest of the world in the event with a bold and innovative strategy that has upended how the race is run. Instead of exchanging the role of who skates up front, the United States has one member lead the entire race, while his teammates use the energy saved by staying in the back to physically push one another forward. The strategy has had success: The Americans set the world record in Salt Lake City in December, and the Norwegians, who won the gold on Tuesday, freely admit to having copied it.

The bronze medal is the first for all the United States skaters, and came in the third, and possibly final, Olympics for Mantia, who is 36. Last week he seemed he seemed resigned to retiring without ever winning an Olympic medal after finishing sixth in the 1,500 meters.

“It’s heartbreaking, you know,” Mantia said at the time. “I really thought that this was my chance. Realistically it was probably my last chance at these Games to medal. I might be able to make the next Olympics, but at 40 I don’t know what my body will be capable of.”

The bronze medal race came less than two hours after the semifinal loss to Russia, a quick turnaround that could have played a role in the decision to hold Mantia out of the semifinal. “It’s a puke-and-rally situation,” Cepuran told reporters about the short timeline after the quarterfinals on Sunday.

In the women’s team pursuit, the favored Canadians defeated the Japanese and set a new Olympic record. The Japanese led the entire race, but on the final curve Nana Takagi seemed to suddenly lose her balance and fell, handing the gold medal to the Canadians. The Netherlands defeated Russia for the bronze.